5 Most Popular Kitchen Countertop Materials in Columbus, OH

Choosing the perfect kitchen countertop is no easy task, especially with so many materials and styles available. Whether you're remodeling to boost your kitchen's functionality, enhance its style, or increase your home’s value, finding a countertop that aligns with your needs, taste, and budget is key.

At JSB Home Solutions, we’ve been guiding Columbus-area homeowners through kitchen remodels since 1978, including helping with countertop selections. While we don’t handle the countertop installation directly, we work closely with reputable suppliers and manufacturers across central Ohio to ensure you get the best fit. We know from experience that countertops aren’t just about appearance—they’re about durability, functionality, and affordability, too.

In this article, we’ll walk you through the most popular countertop materials for Columbus kitchens, from budget-friendly to premium options. You’ll see how each material stacks up in cost, design versatility, and durability, so by the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which one is perfect for your home.

Table of Contents:

• What Are the Top Most Popular Kitchen Countertop Materials in Columbus, OH?
• What Kitchen Countertop Materials are Best in Columbus, Ohio?
• What Factors Should You Consider When Choosing a Kitchen Countertop Material?
• The List of the Top 12 Kitchen Countertop Materials
• Summary of the 13 Best Kitchen Countertop Materials

What Are The Most Popular Kitchen Countertop Materials in Columbus, OH?

• Quartz (Engineered Stone)
• Granite
• Butcher Block (Wood)
• Laminate
• Marble

What Kitchen Countertop Materials are Best in Columbus, Ohio?

At JSB, we often recommend Quartz as the best all-around kitchen countertop material. It’s highly resistant to scratches, dents, chips, and stains—plus, it doesn’t require sealing, making it a low-maintenance choice. While quartz tends to be a bit pricier than other options, the durability and ease of care make it a worthy investment for many homeowners.

For those who love the look of natural stone, Granite is an excellent choice. It’s generally more affordable than quartz and adds a unique, natural warmth to your kitchen. However, granite requires some upkeep, as it can stain more easily, especially from oils and red liquids, and it needs to be resealed every 3-5 years to maintain its beauty and durability.

If budget is a primary concern, Laminate kitchen countertops offer a cost-effective solution. Laminate is easy to cut and install, wipes clean with ease, and is available in a wide range of colors and patterns. While it doesn’t match the durability of stone countertops, using hot pads and cutting boards can help keep your laminate countertop looking great for years to come—perfect for a stylish, budget-friendly kitchen upgrade.

What Factors Should You Consider When Choosing a Kitchen Countertop Material?

When choosing a countertop, consider the following:

• Cost: Evaluate the material cost (excluding installation). Finding a balance between your ideal style and budget is key. Keep in mind that installation expenses can vary greatly depending on your location and kitchen layout.

• Style Compatibility: Your countertop should enhance your overall design aesthetic, whether it’s modern, farmhouse, or somewhere in between.

• Color Variety: Some materials offer a broader range of colors, which can be essential for aligning with your kitchen’s palette and style.

• Durability: Assess how the material stands up to daily wear and tear, including resistance to scratches, stains, and general use.

• Longevity: Decide if you’re seeking a short-term solution or a surface built to last for decades.

• Ease of Maintenance: Certain countertops require more upkeep. Consider the level of maintenance needed to keep your countertop in top condition.

• Heat, Scratch, & Stain Resistance: Your countertop will face regular use, so it’s essential to choose one that can withstand the demands of cooking and food prep.

• Popularity: Current trends can influence design options and ensure your kitchen has a modern, stylish feel.

• Resale Value: High-end countertop materials can enhance your home’s market appeal, attracting potential buyers and adding value to your home.

We want you to feel confident and informed as you choose the countertop material that best fits your needs—even if you don’t choose to work with JSB for your kitchen project. We’ve spent hours researching and gathering essential information to help you make the best choice for your kitchen.

This list of countertop materials is ranked by their popularity among central Ohio homeowners when installing a new countertop.

1. Quartz (Engineered Stone)

• Cost: $75 - $200 per square foot
• Compatible Kitchen Styles/Designs: Modern, traditional, transitional
• Color Options: Nearly unlimited due to engineered pigments
• Durability: Extremely durable; doesn’t need sealing
• Longevity: 25+ years
• Cleaning & Maintenance: Easy to clean with soap and water; low maintenance
• Heat, Scratch & Stain Resistance: Heat and stain-resistant, but can be damaged by extreme heat
• Popularity: One of the most popular choices in modern kitchens
• Resale Value: High; seen as a luxury material and a good investment

Quartz is the most popular choice for kitchen countertops in Columbus, Ohio, and with good reason. For families across central Ohio, quartz offers unmatched durability with resistance to scratches, dents, and stains—perfect for busy kitchens. And since it never needs resealing, it’s a low-maintenance option that homeowners appreciate. The one downside is its higher price, but if you’re looking for a long-lasting, beautiful surface in your Columbus-area kitchen, quartz is worth the investment.

2. Granite

• Cost: $70 - $175 per square foot
• Compatible Kitchen Styles/Designs: Traditional, modern, luxury
• Color Options: Wide range of natural colors and patterns
• Durability: Very durable, but needs sealed every 12 - 18 months
• Longevity: 25+ years
• Cleaning & Maintenance: Requires periodic sealing to prevent staining
• Heat, Scratch & Stain Resistance: Heat-resistant and scratch-resistant, but can stain if not sealed
• Popularity: Extremely popular in many home styles, especially in mid-range to high-end homes
• Resale Value: High; considered a premium material by most buyers

Granite is another favorite in the greater Columbus area, known for its natural beauty and durability. It brings a warm, earthy feel to kitchens while being resistant to heat, scratches, and everyday wear. Although granite requires resealing every few years to prevent staining—especially from oils and red liquids—it remains a solid choice for Columbus homeowners who want the look of natural stone without the higher price tag of quartz.

3. Butcher Block (Wood)

• Cost: $30 - $100 per square foot
• Compatible Kitchen Styles/Designs: Farmhouse, traditional, rustic
• Color Options: Natural wood tones (maple, oak, walnut)
• Durability: Prone to dents and scratches but can be sanded down
• Longevity: 10-20 years with proper maintenance
• Cleaning & Maintenance: Oiling every 1 - 2 months required; avoid water exposure
• Heat, Scratch & Stain Resistance: Sensitive to heat and water, easily scratched but repairable
• Popularity: Growing in popularity for farmhouse and rustic kitchens
• Resale Value: Moderate; adds charm and warmth but requires maintenance

Butcher block countertops are gaining popularity among Columbus-area homeowners seeking a rustic or farmhouse style. The natural wood grain adds warmth and charm to any kitchen, especially when paired with dark or painted cabinets. While butcher block does require regular maintenance to protect it from wear and stains, it can be a wonderful fit for those in central Ohio who love the look of natural wood and don’t mind a bit of upkeep.

4. Laminate

• 

  Cost: $20 - $60 per square foot (least expensive)
• Compatible Kitchen Styles/Designs: Modern, budget-friendly, retro
• Color Options: Wide variety, mimics stone, wood, or solid colors
• Durability: Not very durable; can chip or peel over time
• Longevity: 10-15 years
• Cleaning & Maintenance: Easy to clean with mild soap; avoid harsh chemicals
• Heat, Scratch & Stain Resistance: Susceptible to heat, scratches, and stains
• Popularity: Moderate in budget-conscious remodels; popular in rental properties
• Resale Value: Low to moderate; not a major selling point

Laminate countertops are an ideal budget-friendly option for Columbus homeowners, especially those flipping properties or remodeling rental units. Available in various colors and patterns, laminate can fit many design styles without breaking the bank. However, it’s less durable than stone, so it may not hold up as well in active kitchens with a lot of cooking and baking. Still, for affordable remodeling in central Ohio, laminate offers a practical solution.

5. Marble

• Cost: $100 - $250 per square foot
• Compatible Kitchen Styles/Designs: Elegant, classic, luxury
• Color Options: Limited to natural tones (white, gray, green, pink)
• Durability: Prone to scratches and etching
• Longevity: 20+ years
• Cleaning & Maintenance: Sealing every 2 - 6 months and careful cleaning to avoid damage
• Heat, Scratch & Stain Resistance: Heat-resistant, but easily scratched and stained if not sealed
• Popularity: Highly popular in luxury and high-end homes
• Resale Value: Very high; seen as a premium material by homebuyers

For high-end homes in central Ohio, marble countertops add a luxurious, timeless appeal. The unique veining and classic look make marble a statement piece for kitchens aiming for elegance. However, marble does require regular maintenance to avoid staining and etching, making it a better fit for lower-traffic kitchens. For homeowners in Columbus who want a true luxury finish and don’t mind the upkeep, marble can make a beautiful addition.

Summary of the 5 Most Popular Kitchen Countertop Materials

How Do You Choose the Right Kitchen Countertop Material for You?

Now that you know more about the most popular countertop materials in Columbus, you’re ready to make an informed choice for your kitchen. Whether your top priority is budget, durability, or a specific style, there’s a material that fits your needs and lifestyle. Start by identifying your top 2-3 priorities, then compare them with your budget to find the perfect countertop for your space.

In many cases, updating countertops is just one part of a larger kitchen remodel. If you’re considering a full kitchen makeover in the greater Columbus area, it’s helpful to explore the total kitchen remodeling costs to see how much you can dedicate to countertops. You can also look deeper into quartz and granite options—two of the most popular choices for Columbus homes.

If you’re still unsure which material is right for you, consulting with remodeling professionals in Columbus or the surrounding areas can be a great next step. Local experts can guide you through samples and options, helping you choose a countertop that complements your dream kitchen. With the right choice, you’ll have a kitchen that adds beauty and value to your home in central Ohio. Let’s bring your kitchen vision to life!